The missing pieces of the Karonga earthquake puzzle

19th December

The first quake struck on the evening of Sunday 6th December, then a larger quake the next morning, followed by a series of aftershocks in the Karonga District of Northern Malawi. The ground was shaking as far as Mzuzu 150km away with the biggest quake measuring 5.9 on the Richter scale. My parents who live in Rumphi between Mzuzu and Karonga, ran out of the house during each tremor wondering whether this was final days. Twelve  tremors were felt across three days. Homes and buildings have been damaged, one fatality when a child died after a wall fell on him. The government and Red Cross are providing assistance to the victims of the earthquake but equally the government should also provide answers as to what happened? Do people understand what causes earthquakes:  do they deem it an act of God, punishment from angry ancestors, or a sign of the end of days? None of the reports have  attempted to explain the reason for the quakes beyond stating Malawi is situated in the Rift Valley and the quakes happened near the uranium mining.

Malawi is certainly no stranger to earthquakes. I experienced my first tremor when I was young girl on holiday with my Dad having breakfast at Lingazdi Inn, Lilongwe. The second tremor, I experienced a  few years ago in Blantyre, when the ground beneath my bed shook me out of sleep. In 1989, a 6.6 earthquake killed at least 9 people and injured 100 in central Malawi and left another 50,000 homeless. Malawi sits on the Great Rift Valley,  a 5,000-kilometer-long geologic feature that runs north-south from Lebanon to Mozambique.

Map of Malawi, Karonga in the north

Rift Valley, Lake Malawi is the lake far south on the map

The ground on earth is called a crust and is cut up into  different plates. These plates move apart, stretching and thinning the crust (or the ground) as they move. The plates move because underneath them in the centre of the Earth is a very hot bubbling fluid called magma. In the earth, a fault is a line of fracture in the rocks where the two sides of the fault slide by each other. The movement can be up, down or sideways, and it is caused by pressure and tension in the rock. When a sudden movement happens along one of these fault lines, an earthquake happens. The result of these plates moving is a long chain of depressions, valleys, and deep lakes alongside towering volcanoes like Mount Kilimanjaro.

Now old fashioned, the Richter scale uses a seismometer to measures the magnitude of an earthquake from 1-10,  10 being most epic. A 5.0-5.9 magnitude like the one experienced in Karonga is described as moderate, causing major damage to poorly constructed buildings over small regions and at most slight damage to well-designed buildings. They occur across the world at a frequency of 800 per year.

They have been speculations that the earthquake could be connected to the uranium mining at Kayelekera.  Can mining cause earthquakes? A look at the United States Geological Survey (USGS) website,  show that quakes can be induced by mining in various towns of the US measuring up to about 3.9 on the Richter scale. In 2007, a damning report linked coal mining to Australia’s worst earthquake.

So earthquakes can be caused naturally or man made. They are caused when stress, building up within rocks of the earth’s crust, is released in a sudden jolt. Can uranium mining cause stress powerful enough to cause an earthquake? Open pit mining commenced in Kayelekera in 2008. In open pit mining rocks or minerals  are extracted through a hole in the ground as opposed to tunnelling into the earth. The pits are created by blasting the Earth’s crust. A search on the internet was not able to reveal specific associations between the explosive blasts or uranium mining activity and earthquakes, however what should be seriously considered is the safety of mining a radioactive material in an Earthquake prone area.   Uranium realises a radon, a radioactive gas which causes cancer. Miners are at particular risk through direct contamination from the mine.  Accidents have occurred that have resulted in wide scale exposure to radioactive material through inhalation and ingestion. The location of Malawi in the Rift Valley, makes it prone to earthquakes, with no way of predicting when the next one will happen or how serious it will be. Bearing in mind Kayelekera is near Lake Malawi, it would be catastrophic if an earthquake resulted in contamination of Lake Malawi. Lake Malawi is vital to the nation – as a source of food, water, and tourism. Do the benefits in foreign exchange from the sale of uranium outweigh the possible costs to human life and the environment?

If anyone has pictures of the damage please let me know.

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “The missing pieces of the Karonga earthquake puzzle

  1. “Is uranium mining in karonga a blessing or a curse? If it is a blessing fine. Is it proper to sacrifice people’s health and environment for the sake of investment and employment?” Those are words from an opposition MP in August house. Why earthquakes now soon after mining takes shape?

  2. Pingback: Global Voices Online » Malawi: Bloggers discuss 30 earthquakes in 3 weeks

  3. Pingback: Malawi: Bloggers discuss 30 earthquakes in 3 weeks :: Elites TV

  4. Pingback: Malawi bloggers discuss 30 earthquakes in 3 weeks | Malawi news

  5. Pingback: Global Voices in Swahili » Malawi: Wnablogu wajadili Matetemeko ya Adrdhi 30 Katika Wiki 3

  6. We stay in senga bay, Malawi, on the shore of Lake Malawi. Early in January 2010, we experienced an earthquake in Salima that measured 4.8 (I speak under correction) Although we were about 50 km from the centre of the quake, it caused our house to shudder, groan and some crockery to move on the shelves. To me this was a frightening experience and my first thought was the possibility of a tsunami on the lake, should an underwater quake happen. Is there anybody out there who could perhaps elaborate on this possibility?

    • Ingrid- i was searching the web for news about the earthquake in karonga and came across your posting. i was a peace corps volunteer in malawi from 1979 to 1981 and lived in salima. i worked for the agricultural development project and the project headquarters were at senga bay. there was another pcv named steve who lived at senga bay. we never experienced any earthquakes but there were a lot of erosion problems from wave action on the lake. the project at that time tried using large wire contraptions filled with rocks to help prevent this. How long have you been at senga bay and what do you do there? When i lived in the arae it was a beatiful place with very well kept flower gardens. id really be interested in hearing about whats going on there today.

  7. Ralph, there still is a lot of erosion problems here! (Nothing really changes quickly here!) The rock project is no longer in operation, which is a pity, as we are losing more and more of the lake shore…My husband and I have been here for close to two years. We have a small lodge, with a PADI dive school and a water sports business. Senga is still beautiful, but very neglected.

    • Dear Ingrid,
      Unfortunately govt is being a bit cagey about releasing any kind of information on the survey done by the consultants and no statements with scientific evidence have been released. An earthquake below the lake could cause a tsunami, depending on the magnitude of the quake and where it happens…sorry there is no clear cut answer to your question…but let us hope that nothing catastrophic ever happens….

      Muza

Comments are closed.